IRIS home page STAR legacy modules

pages Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 of nine
Close this window and return to the Main Resources page.



How does linguistic diversity influence classroom performance?

Page 4: Communication

Another important factor that culturally responsive teachers keep in mind is their students' linguistic diversity. To become responsive to linguistic diversity, teachers should familiarize themselves with students' styles of communication, always remembering how challenging education can be for those students whose communication happens to differ from that of the school culture. sun graphic

thumbs up Such variant styles of communication can shape in-class interactions as well as personal ones. For example, in a typical classroom, students are expected to listen attentively to their lessons. Afterward, the teacher might ask specific questions, but the students are expected to wait for acknowledgement before responding. When they do respond, students are usually expected to do so in a manner that is concise and to the point, maintaining eye contact, restricting their physical movements, and checking their emotions. By contrast, culturally responsive teachers understand that some groups of students are accustomed to communicating through:

hispanic boy Culturally responsive teachers also recognize that some students organize their ideas differently than do those who are more familiar with the dominant cultural style. For example, students may use topic association or topic chaining, a circular communication style that omits explanations about the relationships between topics. For teachers more accustomed to a straightforward, linear style of communication, it may sound as though the speaker is rambling and failing to complete his or her thoughts or is unable to think logically.

Alfredo Antiles
Alfredo Artiles, PhD
Professor
Division of Curriculum & Instruction
Arizona State University
Listen to Alfredo Artiles talk about the importance of recognizing and valuing differing storytelling styles. (Time: 1:34)

View Transcript

Keep in Mind

  • Teachers who do not recognize that communicative styles differ might consider interactive styles of communication to be rude and disruptive, requiring disciplinary action.

  • Teachers who judge their way of speaking English to be more correct than the way their students speak (e.g., due to their dialect) might hold inaccurate beliefs about their intelligence and abilities.

Cultural Connection

Mr. Bennett Mr. Bennett realizes that he had made inaccurate assumptions about some of his students based on their communication styles. In order to be more culturally responsive, he makes efforts to:
  • Create a classroom environment that is accepting of all students and respects diversity
  • Learn about the intent behind students' communication rather than reacting negatively to the communication style itself
  • Listen to what students say rather than to how they say it
  • Encourage all students to participate in class discussions and activities


Iris flower

Think about the scenarios outlined below. Try to imagine how culture might influence the following statements. Click on the audio links to hear Donna Ford, an expert in multicultural education, discuss her perspective.

Donna Ford
Donna Ford
Professor of special education and
Betts Chair of Education and Human Development
Vanderbilt University

  • During class, some students participate in the discussions while others sit silent. Could cultural values and beliefs about sharing personal opinions determine participation? Why or why not?
      View Transcript

  • You're engaged in conversation with a student who repeatedly interrupts you. Explain why this behavior could be culturally acceptable for some students. What could you do if this happened in your classroom?
      View Transcript

  • While telling a story, a student jumps around from one idea and incident to the next, without consideration of conventional narrative sequence (i.e., beginning, middle, and end). Could this narrative style be based on culture? Why or why not?
      View Transcript



pages Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 of nine
Close this window and return to the Main Resources page.


The IRIS Center
Special Education Resources for Inclusion,
Scientifically-Validated and Evidence-Based Instructional Strategies